An Update and request for Feedback!

Alright, Prince here. Figured I’d give a small update to let everyone know what’s going on, celebrate my 110+ subscribers, and mostly thank everyone for their commentary, suggestions, wit and support over the years.

Palace: It’s been a damn long wait but we are so fucking close I can smell it. Palace of Unquiet Repose is going to get art, a mapper and probably an editor. Rough concepts of the maps are all done. My initial choice (who I can hint has been featured in my reviews) had to drop out but Malrex knows a lot of talented authors so I have no doubt we can find someone who can capture the atmosphere of opulent aeons-old horror that Palace is positively brimming with. It’s probably going to be a kickstarter so stay tuned on that front. I’m currently in the process of revising each entry based on Malrex’s suggestions. It’s already a certainty that after this one comes out I will be starting a second one called Vaults of Oblivion.

Content: I’ve been alternately following and ignoring your tips, tricks and suggestions so I’d like to take a moment to give all my readers a moment to give me your honest opinion. What would you like to see more of in this blog? Oldschool reviews, OSR Reviews, Age of Dusk stuff, Actual Play reports, Appendix N Bookfaggotry. Let me know in the comments section. And speaking of Bookfagging:


The Compleat Enchanter (Fletcher Pratt & L.Sprague Du Camp):  Ah where have you been all my life? A glaring hole in my Appendix N, finally plugged. I’d had no idea of the influence of the adventures of Harold Shea, a psychologist that figures out a method of translocating himself into worlds of fiction, until I’d read it. Everything from spell components, spellcasting clerics to Steading of the Hill Giant Chief has some origination or root in this witty, imaginative and uproariously funny fantasy series that transports the reader anywhere from the Midgard of the Edda’s to the mythical lands of Spencer’s the Faerie Queene. Funny and clever in a way that is simply not seen anymore in the dreary fantasies of modernity.

Death’s Shadow (Karl Edward Wagner):  A collection of three short stories of the immortal adventurer Kane, and some of his finest, second only to the superb Darkness Weaves. Kane is locked in some forlorn fortress in deepest winter with a werewolf among the guests, must contend with a fanatic Crusader and his Seven fighting Men or is ensnared by the promise of love everlasting by an Immortal lady of the Night. Moody, brutal, thrilling and atmospheric, exactly what I want in my S&S. Dead tree versions are damn hard to get so I hope everyone likes Ebooks.

 Kull of Atlantis (R.E. Howard): A predecessor of the famed Conan, Kull lacks something of the sanguine vivaciousness of Howard’s most famous character, being in general, a lot more broody and celibate. This should in no way not dissuade anyone from checking out his blood-drenched adventures as King of Valusia. Compared to everyone’s favorite Barbarian, Kull’s adversaries have a stronger supernatural character to them, consisting of the by now Classic Snakemen, envious courtiers, the evil wizard Thulsa Doom, a talking cat (or is it!), nightmarish pre-human creatures in buried cities and the cosmic horror of the Silence. Not as good as Conan, but damn tasty.

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms (Luo Ghuanzhong):Maybe my new favorite mythological addition to my personal appendix N? What if someone condensed any doorstopper fantasy series you know into a single behemoth of a book consisting of short chapters that read like 4X game play reports. A century plus of warfare, intrigue, betrayal, wizardy, prophecy and honor across three warring kingdoms, hundreds of characters, gigantic battles and approximately nine thousand schemes, scams, tricks, ruses, connivances etc. Characters die after attempting to hew down sacred trees, piss off wandering uber-wizards, fight barbarians that can control animals and rock storms, scam Wei out of ammunition, invent new weaponry, or are honourably beheaded and buried. A brutal, majestic epic in the China of Ancient Myth.

Ten Billion Days and One Hundred Billion Nights (Ryu Mitsuse): Jesus fights the Buddha and the Asura Queen with wrist lasers in the ruins of a Tokyo Ten Thousand Years in the Future. Do you like obsessive attention to aesthetic detail as an almost incomprehensible saga unfolds across all of human history and time? Do you enjoy philosophizing as you sip your black bush on what exactly Mitsuse meant at the end of Chapter 8, or who exactly the antagonist is, or what they are doing, and why they are doing it? What if you mix that with science fiction and existential concepts that are still pretty radical today and the book was written in 1969? Ten Billion Days is a little impenetrable but also compelling. Good to see the Japanese pendant for hypnotically fascinating nonsense existed before Neon Genesis Evangelion. A book to read alone in a dark room while drinking heavily.

Reviewing Scale: Probably less interesting to anyone here then it is a niggling itch for consistency that I need to fulfill to myself. I think it makes the most sense to use the original TSR adventures as a baseline and compare anything else to that since A) those old adventures are likely to be the most familiar and B) they do in a very real sense determine what comes after. I like the five star scale since it should be immediately apparent in what broad category I place an adventure, regardless of genre preferences.

Peter C. Spahn (Small Niche Games): Overal a very talented, diligent and inspired writer of modules and material, whose work has appeared in Dungeon (I need to check that out sometime), the style of his work tends towards the low and the gritty, with delicious hints of Stephen King-esque surrealist or cosmic horror thrown in. Doesn’t get enough love. By my new scale (adjusted in my reviews):

Chronicles of Ahmerth: *** Chronicles of Ahmerth is not a bad replacement for Mystara if you are looking for something vanilla but inspired, and it helps you don’t have to hunt down fifteen Gazzeteers to do it. I’ll let you know when I figure out how to systematically rate campaign settings.

Blood Moon Rising: ****  I am torn between a High *** and a low **** but BMR is so well crafted and every encounter works seamlessly makes it a very fine low fantasy adventure with a dash of cosmic horror.

Inn of Lost Heroes: **** A no brainer. Great Horror adventure. Maybe the best horror adventure the OSR has done (that I have read).

Pyramid of the Dragon: *** Above average elements with the dragon negotiatin’ but fucking 4 elements in a workmanlike dungeon fuck me.

Atarin’s Delve: **. Not bad but just too little to be anything special.

The Stealer of Children: **** A single fucking flaw (the Stealer’s Howl) shouldn’t detract from a perfect introductory horror adventure with a fantastic twist. B/X meets IT.

Ghoul Keep and the Ghoul Lands: *** Nice concept, tonnes of hooks, but with some implementation problems. On the verge of not making my cutoff. Hell of a sample adventure in the back though.

The Shrine of St. Aleena: ** Homage be damned, this one I didn’t like at all. Artificial, boring encounters in the dungeon.

Oak Grove Whispers: *** Another I can’t believe it’s not WHF adventure with a whiff of faerie-tale. This one is a bit more straightforward. Still has a nice flavor.

Jeff Sparks: Sparks runs Faster Monkey Games and was pretty prolific in the imitative fase of the OSR, when the popular thing was to recreate the style and mood of the adventures of yesteryear. He’s very much a Dnd-as-a-game GM and it shows. Scenario’s are challenging and well constructed but tend to be a bit bland or traditional. Might return to his stuff at a later date.

Black Gem: *** Simple premise, well executed. Party gets captured and left on the haunted graveyard and has to make it through the night.

Skull Mountain: *** A brutal but well constructed assault on the stronghold of an evil cult. Spec-ops DnD with a capital S. One of the most unforgiving scenarios I have seen.

The Hidden Serpent: ** A B1 homage. Don’t Homage B1. You will just remind people that they could also be playing B1. Lacks most of the elements that made B1 great. This is B1 without B1.

Stay tuned for at least one more Winter adventure, a review of an old magazine, but not the one we think, and more of the regular programming. Don’t get Corona and stay safe everyone!

14 thoughts on “An Update and request for Feedback!

  1. The OSR reviews are probably the most useful to me; Oldschool reviews is the category where it is easiest for me to make (hopefully reasonably informed) comments. I think having themes, like running through the B series, is a good idea. But I would write whatever takes your fancy, and is most enjoyable for you.

    I have some of the Spahn modules: Blood Moon Rising is my favourite, taking a neglected theme (the tourney), a nice twist that the myth is far from the truth (and people will not be pleased when this is revealed), mysteries to solve, and plenty of action that the PCs can engage in, or ignore then run from, as they see fit. A clear four stars for me; Inn of Lost Heroes, an intriguing concept well handled, four stars seems correct; Shrine of St. Aleena, I like it a bit more than you do, I remember the goblin tribe being more memorable and distinct than in some offerings, but high two stars would be the upper limit for me; Oak Grove Whispers, nicely done, bonus for being an urban adventure, three stars seems right.

    Update on Palace appreciated.


  2. More bar fights!

    Nah, I’m just fuckin’ around.

    I’m new here but FWIW I like what I’ve been seeing. And having only recently learned of your Palace, I’m keen to see what you’re going to unleash on the world.


  3. Obviously the new OSR reviews are very useful, keep doing those… but I really would love to hear more about the Age of Dusk! The guardians of the highest citadel, those were great, and The Weapon too! Show us what you got Prince.


  4. The OSR reviews are always good to have as a second opinion vs. Bryce, but I also like your recent reviews of the older stuff. Especially how they’re linked by thematic concept for the purpose of finding something specific– good cold weather rules in this case. It’d be fun to see other series with a similar goal (Has there ever been an adventure with good underwater combat? Good sewer levels? etc.). And of course the ever-continuing chronicles of The Fallen King James and friends.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. More OSR setting reviews – Melan does them only rarely and Bryce not at all. Your Carcosa play reports were great – maybe you could do that B-series campaign you mentioned? Also, since you’re going back and reexamining your old reviews, Stuart’s Deep Carbon Observatory Remastered might be worth taking a look at whenever it comes out.


  6. [Oldschool reviews, OSR Reviews, Age of Dusk stuff, Actual Play reports, Appendix N Bookfaggotry]

    Frankly I like them all. Perhaps just let run-of-the-mill d20 and Dragon Magazine stuff sink into oblivion, and save your verve for the most outrageously bad ones ?


  7. I’m gonna second, third, or whatever on more Age of Dusk content. I still go back through and read those Age of Dusk posts whenever I’m running low on creativity and need a boost. If you ever wrote a setting book on it, I’d read it in a heart beat. Also, since I’m going to shamelessly shill my own crap, if you wouldn’t mind taking a look at my SWN adventures. I want to do another one, but I think the other two need cleaning up and tightening before I go and do another one.
    Other than that, just keep doing what you’re doing warfighter.


  8. Oldschool reviews
    Yes please … I don’t know much about the modules of old so any information is most welcome. I of course know the iconic modules, but there are surely many forgotten treasures still waiting 😉

    OSR Reviews
    Again, yes plase. You and Bryce are my main source of readable, new content to try at my table.

    Age of Dusk stuff
    I love world-building and designing settings and yours has a very nice vibe to it. more is always welcome here.

    Actual Play reports
    Can’t say I care much about other play reports. Maybe if you include some asventure design related stuff or “usable at the table” informations. But play reports are simply not my thing.

    Appendix N Bookfaggotry
    While I love to read a good book I simply haven’T got the time nowadays.
    Any good tips are appreciated, but I probably won’t read them for a while 😉

    Themed review series
    Basically what Slick said above.
    A series of reviews tied together by a common theme or a big question you want to answer seems like a good idea.


  9. Perhaps LESS reviews and reading book tomfoolery….and more worky worky on Palace…eh? How about that concept? We got a schedule to keep!!!

    (….and more Old School and OSR reviews please….and after Palace’s release, perhaps a mere snippet of what’s in your brain for Vaults…and…you interviewed Bryce already, how about Melan or someone random once in awhile for shits and giggles…)

    Liked by 1 person

  10. Late to the party, but I’d vote yes to more reviews (old school and OSR alike), indifferent to Age of Dusk stuff, no to Actual Play reports (unless they include more than just recapping, as Grützi said), and yes to Bookfaggotry.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s